Pikachu Illustrator vs Blastoise Presentation Card: which is the better Pokémon TCG investment?

Comparing Pikachu Illustrator (Vintage Promos & Trophies, 1998) and Blastoise Presentation Card (Vintage Promos & Trophies, 1998) as Pokémon TCG investments. PSA 10 bands, risk, and upside compared.

Pikachu IllustratorBlastoise Presentation Card
SetVintage Promos & Trophies (1998)Vintage Promos & Trophies (1998)
RarityTrophy PromoTrophy / Pre-Production
PSA 10 band$1,000,000-$6,000,000$300,000-$700,000
Raw band$300,000-$1,000,000n/a (only 2 known)
Risk levelLowLow
Investment score5/55/5

Pikachu Illustrator

The single most valuable Pokémon card ever made. Awarded to winners of a 1998 CoroCoro Comic illustration contest in Japan. Estimated 39 copies known to exist; ~7 confirmed PSA 10. Logan Paul famously paid $5.275M for a PSA 10 in 2022.

Check Pikachu Illustrator prices →

Blastoise Presentation Card

Pre-production trophy card given to Magic the Gathering parent company Wizards of the Coast as a presentation piece. Only 2 known copies. Sold at Heritage Auction for $360,000 in 2021.

Check Blastoise Presentation Card prices →

Detailed comparison coming soon.